Many people are only vaguely aware of panning laws, which makes sense—if something ain’t broke, there’s no desire to fix it. But panning laws can, in fact, cause issues, and the whole topic is somewhat shrouded in mystery. So, let’s dispel the confusion, and pay particular attention to how panning laws apply to DAWDefinition:
(Digital Audio Workstation): A computer program or stand-alone device that provides digital audio recording, editing, and mixing. programs that do recording and mixing.
1. Panning laws govern the perceived sound level when panning a mono signal across the stereo field. When a mono input feeds a stereo busDefinition:
1. In audio, a common point that combines multiple signals, as in a "mix bus." 2. In computers, a path that interconnects various elements for transferring data among those elements., the panning law determines how you perceive the sound level as the audio sweeps from one side of the stereo field to the other. Without panning laws, panning the sound to the center would sound louder than having it panned to one side or the other.
2. The panning laws in DAWs have their roots in analog mixing consoles. While it may seem that the perceived level would just stay the same as you panDefinition:
Horizontal pivot of a camera or light, opposite of Tilt, or the placement of a sound element in stereo or surround sound., that’s not necessarily the case. If a hardware mixer’s pan control had a linear taperDefinition:
On a control, the relationship, linear or non-linear, between position and output. potentiometerDefinition:
A rotary or sliding electrical control, based on resistance, typically with three terminals. Rotating or sliding the control increases the resistance between a center and end terminal, while reducing resistance between the center and the other terminal. Also called Fader when applied to audio levels. See also: Resistor. (in other words, a constant rate of resistance change as you turned it), then the sound was louder when panned to center. To compensate, hardware mixers used non-linear resistance tapers to drop the level, typically by -3 dBDefinition:
1. A deciBel is a logarithmic ratio between two quantities, and is a nonlinear measurement that mimics human perception. 2. A unit expressing sound levels relative to a nominal level just audible by the average human ear, and equal to 1/10th of a Bel. 3. (slang) Database. RMSDefinition:
(Root Mean Square) An accurate measurement of average power that can be produced by an amplifier, or consumed by a speaker, or generated by an audio signal.., at the center. This gave an apparent level that was constant (as in constant power) as you panned across the stereo soundstage.
3. Panning laws aren’t really laws. There’s no panning law specification or standard, so some engineers took subjective liberties with audio’s perceived level when it was panned across the stereo field. Some dropped the center level a little more than usual so that the sides would “pop” more, or to create extra space for vocalists who were panned to center. Then again, some didn’t drop the center level at all, and some did custom tweaks.
4. Panning laws matter with DAWs, even though they don’t have hardware mixers. Different DAWs defaultDefinition:
A value assumed initially by a device, particularly a computer-based device, until changed. to different panning laws (Fig. 1). This is why duplicating a mix on different DAWs can yield different results, and lead to foolish online discussions about how one DAW sounds “punchier” or “wimpier” than another if someone brings in audio files, and then sets the panning and faders to what they think are identical settings.
![1_Panning Laws](/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/1_Panning-Laws.png)
In Fig. 1, a mono signal of the same level feeds each pair of meters, and each pair is subject to different panning laws. The left meter of the pair shows the level when panned fully (L)eft, and the right meter of the pair shows the level when panned to center. Note the difference in levels with the panpotDefinition:
A mixer control for placing a signal in the stereo soundstage by varying the level going to the left, optionally center, and right channels. See also: Dual Panpot. panned to one side or centered.
(1) shows an equal power law with a 0 dB center. This boosts signals panned hard left or right by 3 dB, but when panned to center, causes no output level reduction in either channelDefinition:
1. In radio, television, citizen's band radio, and other wireless communications modes, a specific frequency for communication. 2. In mixers and video, an input or output signal path with controls. 3. In MIDI, one of 16 data paths.. (2) is similar, but has a -3 dB center. This means there’s no boost when panned hard left or right, but either channel is down by -3 dB when panned to center. (3) shows a linear panning curve, where hard panning left or right causes no boost—but this particular curve adds a -6 dB drop for each channel when panned to the center, so that the sides are more prominent. This is more about having constant gainDefinition:
The amount of amplification provided by an amplifier circuit, expressed in dB or numerically as in "3X" = "3 times". than constant power as you pan. (4) is the panning law for a stereo balanceDefinition:
The ratio of a stereo signal's left channel to its right channel, often controlled with a knob on a mixer. control, where the measured signal level is constant at all times, regardless of the panning position.
Note that equal power options often have two possible tapers, sine/cosine and square root. You don’t need to dig too much deeper into this, because the levels with hard panned and centered signals are the same; there’s only a subtle variation to the curve between the hard panned and center positions. Compared to the sine/cosine option, the square root option results in slightly less level difference as you move toward the extreme left or right, and slightly more level difference as you move toward the center.
5. How to make sure you’re using the right law. You’ll typically set a global pan law as a preference, as with Steinberg Cubase or Pro Tools, for individual tracks by using a menu for a panning module, as with PreSonus Studio One (Fig. 2), or on a per track/bus basis, which is what Magix Samplitude does.
![2_Dual Pan Module](/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/2_Dual-Pan-Module.png)
The pan law you choose can affect a mix’s overall sound if you have a lot of mono sound sources (with stereo channels, panpots are balance controls, which is a whole other topic). So try mixes with different laws, choose a law you like, and stick with it. I prefer -3 dB center, sin/cos taper, and constant power; the signal level stays at 0dB when panned right or left, but drops by -3 dB in each channel when centered. This is also how I built hardware mixers back in the day, so it’s familiar territory. Furthermore, most DAWs include this option, so when collaborating, it’s easy to match pan law curves.
Do note that if the end file is going to be collapsed to mono, you’re best off using a -6 dB pan law so that there isn’t a big perceived level change when you listen to the final mono track compared to your original stereo mix. Also, if you’re a fan of putting dynamicsDefinition:
In a musical performance, changes in overall volume levels, often accompanied by timbral changes. Example: Classical symphonic music has a wide dynamic range, while dance mixes have a much narrower dynamic range. processing in the master bus, any processing will react differently depending on which pan law you used. Even acoustics come into play here, because the center-channel summing in an acoustic space will vary, depending on the space itself.
Ultimately, with few exceptions, it doesn’t matter which one you use as long as you’re doing projects in the same DAW. You might like having audio panned hard to the left or right to be a little louder...or not. However, if you import an OMF file from another DAW or need to duplicate a mix from another DAW, ask what panning law was used in creating the file. Hopefully, you’ll be able to match it.